Nicola Sirchia

How far can experience take you when the challenge is new?

By Nicola Sirchia. Published . 2 minute read.

One-minute version. AI avatar and AI voice, made from my own photo and voice.

The short answer

Experience takes you a long way when the challenge looks like one you have met before. When it has never happened before, experience alone can mislead you, because it is made of things that already happened. It works best as a source of good questions, and as an early warning when an experiment starts going in the wrong direction.

Is everything we call innovation really new?

We call a lot of things innovation. A few months ago I joined a digital round table with some very bright people, and the conversation turned to that word. The more I listened, the more I noticed that many of the "innovations" on the table were really built on experience. Good ideas, well executed. But experience is, by definition, made of things that already happened.

When does experience mislead?

Experience is very good at recognising patterns. That is exactly why it can mislead us when the pattern changes. Three situations I see today:

Recognising these situations too quickly is often the first mistake.

So should a leader put experience aside?

No. I don't think the answer is to put experience aside. It gives you the questions worth asking. It also tells you early when an experiment is heading the wrong way, before the numbers do.

What do leaders who innovate well have in common?

Judgementthat comes from years in the job
Curiosityof someone who has just arrived
The leaders I have seen innovate well combine both.

They are comfortable saying "I haven't seen this before" in a meeting. And they give their teams the time and the budget to find out.

Experience tells you where you've been. It shouldn't decide where you go next.

Sources

This piece comes from my own work with teams. It uses no outside data.